Managed Firewalls vs. Traditional Firewalls Explained

Strong network security is more important nowadays in this complex digital world. As businesses increasingly rely on their IT infrastructure to store sensitive data, manage operations, and communicate with clients, safeguarding that infrastructure becomes paramount. This is where the firewall plays an indispensable role in defending against possible attacks.

When it comes to selecting the right firewall solutions, businesses often find themselves choosing between managed firewalls vs. traditional firewalls. Understanding the differences between these two options is essential for enterprises to make educated decisions regarding their network security requirements. In this blog, we’ll explore the key differences between managed firewalls and traditional firewalls, offering a comprehensive guide to help you choose the right solution for your business.

What is a Traditional Firewall?

Traditional firewalls serve as the first line of defense in network security that monitors and regulates network traffic that comes and goes according to predefined security rules. It functions at the network layer  (Layer 3) of the OSI model, primarily inspecting packets for suspicious activity.

Advantages of Traditional Firewall

• Full Control – Organizations have direct access to firewall configurations, allowing them to implement security policies tailored to their specific needs.

• Customization – Traditional firewalls can be highly customizable, enabling businesses to adjust settings according to their unique network architecture.

• Immediate Adjustments – Changes can be made quickly without relying on external service providers, ensuring that security measures can adapt to new threats promptly.

Disadvantages of Traditional Firewall

• Limited Security – They are susceptible to contemporary cyberthreats such as sophisticated malware and zero-day vulnerabilities as they frequently lack advanced threat detection capabilities.

• Manual Updates – IT professionals must manually install updates and patches, which can lead to security flaws if they are delayed or ignored.

• No Application Awareness – Traditional firewalls cannot identify applications, limiting their effectiveness in enforcing application-level security policies.

What is a Next-Generation Firewall (NGFW)?

Next-generation firewalls (NGFWs) are designed to address the limitations of traditional firewalls by incorporating additional layers of security and intelligence. They operate across multiple layers (3 to 7) of the OSI model, enabling more granular control over network traffic.

Advantages of Next Generation Firewall

• Proactive Threat Protection – NGFWs use sophisticated threat detection systems, such as Intrusion Prevention Systems (IPS) and Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS), to detect and prevent suspicious behaviour before it escalates.

• Application Awareness – These firewalls can discern and manage traffic based on applications rather than just IP addresses or ports, allowing for more precise policy enforcement.

• Unified Security – NGFWs integrate various security functions into a single solution, including firewall capabilities, VPN support, antivirus features, and more.

Disadvantages of Next Generation Firewall

• Less Direct Control – Organizations may have less direct control over configurations compared to traditional firewalls due to the complexity of NGFWs.

• Difficult to Manage – The advanced features of NGFWs require skilled personnel for effective management, which can increase operational complexity.

• Dependence on Provider – Many organizations rely on third-party providers for management and updates, which may lead to concerns about service quality and responsiveness.

Traditional Firewalls vs. Next-Generation Firewalls

While both traditional and next-generation firewalls are designed to protect networks, they differ significantly in their capabilities and approach to security. Let’s break down the key differences –

1. Inspection Depth

• Traditional Firewalls – They mainly check basic things like where the data is coming from (IP address), where it’s going (ports), and what kind of data it is (protocols). It’s like checking the label on a package to see where it came from and where it’s going.

• NGFWs – They do much deeper checks by looking at the actual contents of the data packets. It’s like opening the package to make sure the contents are safe, not just looking at the label.

2. Layer of Operation

• Traditional Firewalls – These work mainly at the “network” level (basic packet filtering) and the “transport” layer (how the data is transferred) of the OSI model.

• NGFWs – They work at more levels, including the “application” layer. This means they can look at and control specific apps and the behaviour of the traffic, giving more detailed protection.

3. Application Awareness

• Traditional Firewalls – They don’t know what kind of apps are running or what the data inside the packet does. They just block or allow traffic based on its general characteristics.

• NGFWs – They can identify and control specific applications, even if the app is using unusual ports to communicate. For example, they can block a game app but allow email apps to run.

4. Threat Detection

• Traditional Firewalls – They mostly detect known threats based on patterns. But they struggle with new or unknown types of attacks (like zero-day threats).

• NGFWs – They are much better at spotting both known and unknown threats. They use advanced tools like intrusion detection and prevention systems (IDS/IPS), and even isolate suspicious files in a “sandbox” to check if they are harmful.

5. User Identity Awareness

• Traditional Firewalls – They typically don’t know who is using the network; they just look at the device’s IP address.

• NGFWs – They can link network activity to specific users or devices, helping enforce security based on who’s trying to access the network. This provides more control.

6. Security Updates

• Traditional Firewalls – They must be manually updated to stay updated with threats, which can be time-consuming and result in security flaws.

• NGFWs – They automatically update, so they’re always ready to handle new threats without waiting for you to do anything.

7. Cost and Performance

• Traditional Firewalls – These are usually cheaper and faster, but they might need extra tools to provide the same level of protection as NGFWs.

• NGFWs – They’re more expensive but offer stronger security features. They might be a little slower because of all the extra checks they perform, but the trade-off is better protection.

Conclusion

Both managed firewalls and traditional firewalls offer valuable network security features, but the right choice depends on your organization’s IT infrastructure, resources, and security requirements. If you’re looking for a hassle-free, scalable, and expert-supported solution, a managed firewall is the way to go. For businesses that require more control and have the capacity to manage their own security, a traditional firewall may be a better fit.

To learn more about firewall solutions and how they can improve your network security, consider reaching out to an IT consulting Dubai provider. They may offer advice on the optimal firewall services for your company and assist in determining your needs.

At ITCompany Dubai, we specialize in providing tailored IT solutions, including managed firewalls, to businesses across Dubai and beyond. Get in touch with us right away to find out how we can improve your IT infrastructure and safeguard your network.

Also, read 📖: What Is an Open SIP Phone System?